1986-04-10 N.E.C., Birmingham, England, UK: Difference between revisions

From DM Live - the Depeche Mode live encyclopedia for the masses
Jump to navigationJump to search
No edit summary
No edit summary
 
(28 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
== Notes ==
== Notes ==


A very good recording. This FM broadcast is sourced from a second-generation cassette tape. Thanks to darkdevoted for providing the cassette.
Hula was the support act.


== Track list ==
[[Black Celebration]], [[A Question Of Time]], [[Blasphemous Rumours]], [[Stripped]], [[Something To Do]], and [[More Than A Party]] from this concert were officially released across various editions of the [[A Question Of Time]] single release, the "X2" box set, the [[Black Celebration (album)]] reissue, as part of the iTunes "The Complete Depeche Mode" compilation, and the 12" Singles Box Set series.


#[4:57] [[Black Celebration]]
Most versions of [[A Question Of Time]] and [[More Than A Party]] from these official releases are labeled as "Live Remix", except for [[More Than A Party]] which also appears on the "X2" box set. On the 12" singles releases, [[A Question Of Time]]'s "Live Remix" is named as such because it crossfades with the "New Town Mix" of the song, and [[More Than A Party]]'s "Live Remix" corrects an incorrect sound played after the first "this isn't a party, it's a whole lot more" at the beginning of the song. The "X2" box set version of the song does not have the corrective overdub. Furthermore, the "X2" box set versions seem to be mastered differently and have significantly less reverb than the other commercially released versions as well as the audio which was broadcast over FM radio.
#[4:16] [[A Question Of Time]]
#[5:25] [[It's Called A Heart]]
#[5:34] [[Everything Counts]]
#[2:49] [[It Doesn't Matter Two]] (*)
#[4:35] [[A Question Of Lust]] (*)
#[5:26] [[Blasphemous Rumours]]
#[6:27] [[Stripped]]
#[3:51] [[Something To Do]]
#[5:13] [[Master And Servant]]
#[4:35] [[People Are People]]
#[1:42] Outro
*Total time: 54:50


== Lineage ==
Commercially, [[Blasphemous Rumours]] is exclusively found on the "X2" box set. The song is erroneously labeled in the artwork booklet as having been recorded by Swiss Radio DRS3 (i.e. from the [[1984-11-30 St. Jacobs Sporthalle, Basel, Switzerland|1984 Basel concert]]), but the audio is truly from this 1986 Birmingham concert. These audio examples of [[Blasphemous Rumours]] showcase the differences in mixing and mastering between the audio released on the "X2" box set and the radio broadcast audio:


NHK (Japan) FM broadcast -> ... -> cassette (Maxell XLII-S60) -> Onkyo TA-2055 tape deck (heads cleaned before transferring; high position, no noise reduction setting, no Accubias setting, output level at 7 out of 11) -> RCA -> ASUS Xonar DX -> Adobe Audition CS6 (32-bit / 192 khz) -> 50% 6dB noise reduction, DC bias removed -> WAV (32/48; 100% quality & pre/post filter during sample rate conversion) -> sped up by 4.0% using Audacity 2.0.3 -> WAV (32/48) -> tracks split via cuesheet to FLAC level 8 (24/48) -> FLAC level 8 (16/44) using foobar2000 v.1.2.9, SoX resampler plugin (44.1khz, best quality)
*"X2" version:
Generation: FM2
<html5media>https://media.dmlive.wiki/stream/samples/br-x2.m4a</html5media>
Transferred by ligushka


== Line up ==
*Radio broadcast version:
<html5media>https://media.dmlive.wiki/stream/samples/br-radio.m4a</html5media>


*Dave Gahan - lead vocals
The live version of [[Blasphemous Rumours]] on the original 12" releases of [[A Question Of Lust]] and the 12" Singles Box Set is correctly from the [[1984-11-30 St. Jacobs Sporthalle, Basel, Switzerland|1984 Basel concert]], albeit similarly with completely different mixing and mastering compared to the version prepared for radio broadcast.
*Martin L. Gore - keyboards, backing vocals, occasional lead vocals (*)
*Andrew Fletcher - keyboards
*Alan Wilder - keyboards, backing vocals


All songs written by Martin L. Gore.
These audio examples of [[Something To Do]] showcase the differences in mixing and mastering between the audio released on the "X2" box set and the radio broadcast audio:


== Download ==
*"X2" version:
<html5media>https://media.dmlive.wiki/stream/samples/std-x2.m4a</html5media>


*[http://www.dimeadozen.org/torrents-details.php?id=438276 DIME link]
*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMTzpdpBWRM&list=OLAK5uy_kCm59LtRh0rLAPaBjI5Ghzcdbnga_c6gE&index=18 "Singles Box Set" version:]
<html5media>https://media.dmlive.wiki/stream/samples/std-singlesboxset.m4a</html5media>
 
Additionally, the "X2" version of [[Something To Do]] contains the distorted introduction noise at the beginning of the song. The officially released and radio broadcast variants do not have the introduction noise.
 
These audio examples of [[More Than A Party]] showcase the corrective overdub to the keyboard parts heard on the "Live Remix" version, as well as the differences in mixing and mastering between the audio releases:
 
*"X2" version:
<html5media>https://media.dmlive.wiki/stream/samples/mtap-x2.m4a</html5media>
 
*[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l8PS7al6Q44&list=OLAK5uy_kCm59LtRh0rLAPaBjI5Ghzcdbnga_c6gE&index=23 "Singles Box Set" version:]
<html5media>https://media.dmlive.wiki/stream/samples/mtap-singlesboxset.m4a</html5media>
 
Strangely, [[Stripped]] is missing the introduction noise on all versions except on the 2006 remaster bonus disc of [[Black Celebration]], and the Japanese NHK radio broadcast.
 
Though [[Black Celebration]], [[A Question Of Time]], [[Stripped]], [[Master And Servant]], and [[People Are People]] appear on the "X2" box set, those versions are from the "101" live album release and not this 1986 Birmingham concert.
 
{{Template:BC}}
 
== Sources ==
 
*[[1986-04-10 N.E.C., Birmingham, England, UK/Source 1|Source 1]] is the most complete, best sounding FM broadcast recording, created from multiple sources. This is "Revision B" of the rework created in 2024.
*[[1986-04-10 N.E.C., Birmingham, England, UK/Source 2|Source 2]] is a DAT master recording of a 1991 Swiss radio rebroadcast which includes [[Shake The Disease]].
*[[1986-04-10 N.E.C., Birmingham, England, UK/Source 3|Source 3]] is a 2024 remaster of a second-generation cassette copy of the 1987 NHK Japanese radio broadcast, improved with 4 better-quality songs from the "Rated PG" bootleg.


[[Category:FM broadcasts]]
[[Category:1986 Black Celebration Tour]]
[[Category:Download available]]
[[Category:Download available]]
[[Category:Officially released]]

Latest revision as of 09:03, 4 May 2024

Notes

Hula was the support act.

Black Celebration, A Question Of Time, Blasphemous Rumours, Stripped, Something To Do, and More Than A Party from this concert were officially released across various editions of the A Question Of Time single release, the "X2" box set, the Black Celebration (album) reissue, as part of the iTunes "The Complete Depeche Mode" compilation, and the 12" Singles Box Set series.

Most versions of A Question Of Time and More Than A Party from these official releases are labeled as "Live Remix", except for More Than A Party which also appears on the "X2" box set. On the 12" singles releases, A Question Of Time's "Live Remix" is named as such because it crossfades with the "New Town Mix" of the song, and More Than A Party's "Live Remix" corrects an incorrect sound played after the first "this isn't a party, it's a whole lot more" at the beginning of the song. The "X2" box set version of the song does not have the corrective overdub. Furthermore, the "X2" box set versions seem to be mastered differently and have significantly less reverb than the other commercially released versions as well as the audio which was broadcast over FM radio.

Commercially, Blasphemous Rumours is exclusively found on the "X2" box set. The song is erroneously labeled in the artwork booklet as having been recorded by Swiss Radio DRS3 (i.e. from the 1984 Basel concert), but the audio is truly from this 1986 Birmingham concert. These audio examples of Blasphemous Rumours showcase the differences in mixing and mastering between the audio released on the "X2" box set and the radio broadcast audio:

  • "X2" version:

  • Radio broadcast version:

The live version of Blasphemous Rumours on the original 12" releases of A Question Of Lust and the 12" Singles Box Set is correctly from the 1984 Basel concert, albeit similarly with completely different mixing and mastering compared to the version prepared for radio broadcast.

These audio examples of Something To Do showcase the differences in mixing and mastering between the audio released on the "X2" box set and the radio broadcast audio:

  • "X2" version:

Additionally, the "X2" version of Something To Do contains the distorted introduction noise at the beginning of the song. The officially released and radio broadcast variants do not have the introduction noise.

These audio examples of More Than A Party showcase the corrective overdub to the keyboard parts heard on the "Live Remix" version, as well as the differences in mixing and mastering between the audio releases:

  • "X2" version:

Strangely, Stripped is missing the introduction noise on all versions except on the 2006 remaster bonus disc of Black Celebration, and the Japanese NHK radio broadcast.

Though Black Celebration, A Question Of Time, Stripped, Master And Servant, and People Are People appear on the "X2" box set, those versions are from the "101" live album release and not this 1986 Birmingham concert.

Set list

  1. Christmas Island
  2. Black Celebration
  3. A Question Of Time
  4. Fly On The Windscreen
  5. Shake The Disease
  6. Leave In Silence
  7. It's Called A Heart
  8. Everything Counts
  9. It Doesn't Matter Two (*)
  10. A Question Of Lust (*)
  11. Blasphemous Rumours
  12. New Dress
  13. Stripped
  14. Something To Do
  15. Master And Servant
  16. Photographic
  17. People Are People
  18. Boys Say Go!
  19. Just Can't Get Enough
  20. More Than A Party

Sources

  • Source 1 is the most complete, best sounding FM broadcast recording, created from multiple sources. This is "Revision B" of the rework created in 2024.
  • Source 2 is a DAT master recording of a 1991 Swiss radio rebroadcast which includes Shake The Disease.
  • Source 3 is a 2024 remaster of a second-generation cassette copy of the 1987 NHK Japanese radio broadcast, improved with 4 better-quality songs from the "Rated PG" bootleg.